cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
mfranz
Level 16 Champion
Level 16 Champion

Creating Assets from Virtual Machines

Hi,

It used to be best practice not to create Assets from Virtual Machines in FNMS. Now, technically it is easily possible, just clicking "Create an asset" from the "All Inventory" view. But a customer noticed a difference between Computers and Virtual Machines, that may still be going back to the mentioned best practice.

For Computers, the Linked asset field can be changed from the Inventory. And more importantly, there is this little symbol to drill down to the asset.

2019-09-20_09h25_18.png

For Virtual Machines I cannot manipulate the data from the Inventory and easy drill down to the Asset is also not possible. Interestingly from the Asset perspective, there is no difference.

I have tested this behaviour in a 2019 R1 U5 environment. I believe the customer is on 2018 something. Now for my actual questions:

  • Is this by design?
  • If so, why?
  • Could this be made an enhancement so that VMs work the same?

Best regards,

Markward

Softline Group is Europe's leading independent expert in Software Asset Management.

This thread has been automatically locked due to inactivity.

To continue the discussion, please start a new thread.

2 Replies
kclausen
Level 15 Flexeran
Level 15 Flexeran

Under System Settings-->Inventory, there is a check box named "Link virtual machine to the same asset as VM host" that allows Inventory Devices that are a virtual machine to be linked to the Hardware Asset of the Physical Host VM.  The theory here is that a virtual machine is NOT a physical asset.  With this option set, you can select a virtual machine and link it to an Asset, as long as you have previously created an Asset for the corresponding Inventory Device of the VM Host.  In this scenario, the Hardware Asset is now linked to multiple Inventory Device items (the VM Host and all of the Guest VMs).

With this feature, there is still a limitation where if you have an orphan Virtual Machine that is not linked to a VM Host, you will not be able to create a Hardware Asset for it.

Kirk

Hi Kirk,

The problem is not so much that one cannot link inventory and asset. It is more about not being able to navigate those links in the UI. Even if I linked the VM to the same Asset as the host, I still wouldn't be able to drill down that data in the UI.

Would you consider overthinking the definition of asset in this context? VMs are resouces, they contribute to company success, they cost upkeep, etc.

It is clearly possible to link those items, so why is FNMS making the difference? Is there a technical reason? It seems more complicated to me to make that difference, than to just handle Computers, VMHosts and VMs the same (in this regard).

Best regards,

Markward

Softline Group is Europe's leading independent expert in Software Asset Management.